Why pay for Transfer Analysis for a final salary pension?

For many years, even before it became compulsory, UK advisers specialising in pension transfers offered clients pension transfer analysis.I can recall being involved with the first transfer analysis systems about 22 years ago.

Outside the UK, until April 2015, there was no requirement for a non-UK adviser to provide a transfer analysis based on UK requirements. This often meant a  transfer analysis being provided without taking into account the charges (something that was illegal in the UK) and so many thousands of expats will have moved their UK pensions without any real idea of the current UK pension  position and the impact those undisclosed charges will ultimately have on their pensions, nor of the guarantees given away, nor even the real cost of the advice they have received. The ubiquitous 1% is often quoted, when it is complete nonsense! This is a ticking time-bomb.

Since April 2015, any expat that is considering transferring a UK pension from a funded final salary scheme can only do this if a UK IFA with pension transfer permissions provides a transfer analysis. However, this can lead to a UK IFA refusing to sign off the transfer if the pension transfer analysis shows that the investor could be worse off as a result of the transfer. Unfortunately, some overseas advisers are being assisted with “sign offs” by third party connections,  usually associated with the trustees that will benefit from the transfer; really not good!

What is a transfer analysis?

In its simplest form, it is a set of calculations and assumptions that indicate how hard a transferred UK pension fund will have to work if it is to match the guarantees being lost. One of the key indicators of a transfer analysis is the Critical Yield- showing the annual return the funds would need to match the existing benefits. Additionally, such a transfer analysis should also show how the funds need to perform in retirement to ensure the fund does not get spent too early. There are many other factors that need to be taken into account but the transfer analysis is the starting point of any recommendation. 

An analogy

House falling down

Depending on the work involved, the cost of a transfer analysis can be a few hundred pounds, but can save literally thousands for the consumer. It is similar in many ways to a structural survey of a house that can also cost several hundred pounds,  but no-one would buy a house without knowing that it was safe to buy.

Anyone using a mortgage to buy a house will have to provide a survey to the bank. Anyone buying an expensive older property for cash would not hesitate to pay for a survey before parting with their money.

What happens if the survey results are bad?

The bank would decline or reduce the mortgage offer. The cash buyer would try and reduce  the asking price or walk away. In both cases, the feeling would be that the survey was money well spent as the relatively small upfront cost could have saved tens of thousands of pounds or even more than that!

Transfer Analysis

The transfer analysis may also produce a result that was not expected that could potentially identify a large shortfall of many tens of thousands of pounds if existing pension guarantees are given up. Since pension funds are similar in size to house values in many cases, surely the cost of the transfer analysis should be seen as good value even if the advice is to leave the pension alone.

The transfer analysis offers a sort of insurance policy against making a costly mistake, often driven by the hype of the offshore salesmen looking to get a chunk of your pension. Remember, these people will be long gone once you discover the real cost of the advice given all those years ago.

A transfer analysis may work out to be one of the best investments you ever make.


Since publishing this blog, this issue has now been picked up by Money Marketing-  International advisers are struggling to keep up with new pension transfer regulations

The articles says “International advisers are struggling to keep up with new pension transfer regulations, citing high fees and a reluctance from UK advisers to form partnerships.”

This tells us two things, that many offshore advisers are not equipped to deal with the high level of expertise  needed to advise on this subject  and it shows a failure to disclose that proper fee based financial planning is significantly LESS expensive than the no-fee/high commission advice model offered to expats. There are only a handful of firms that have all the right qualifications, licences and experience to provide expats with the pensions advice they need and expats should avoid the offers of free financial advice as the real costs are hidden

The views expressed in this article are not to be construed as personal advice. You should contact a qualified and ideally regulated adviser in order to obtain up to date personal advice with regard to your own personal circumstances. If you do not then you are acting under your own authority and deemed “execution only”. The author does not except any liability for people acting without personalised advice, who base a decision on views expressed in this generic article. Where this article is dated then it is based on legislation as of the date. Legislation changes but articles are rarely updated, although sometimes a new article is written; so, please check for later articles or changes in legislation on official government websites, as this article should not be relied on in isolation.



Chris Lean

Chris is a Chartered Financial Planner who writes blogs and articles to simplify and explain some of the financial issues that affect UK expats. Subjects include; hot topics, regulation and the ever-changing world of finance.




Related Stories:
Advise Me

Share this story